What makes
tango music so seductive is the way it sweeps over you,
like a wave.
Hacienda de
Argentina, an elegant South American steakhouse on the
upper East Side, has the same effect.
The aura of
Argentina is so complete (dark woods, dripping table
candelabras, tawny cowhides, chairs carved like chess
pawns), you'll wonder if your cabbie, so busy on the
phone, made a wrong turn to Buenos Aires. The family
pictures on the wall and the majestic communal table
anchoring the room suggest you've landed in some
dignitary's hacienda.
If there's
a "host" gene, the French woman who greets you at the
door has it in spades. Rarely have I felt so genuinely
welcomed in a dining room.
She'll
suggest a lemonada, the refreshing house cocktail that
marries mojito and caipirinha with a toast of Champagne.
Accept, by all means.
Meat
grilled a la parilla is king here. Per tradition,
grilling is low and slow, so order smaller dishes while
you wait.
I had given
up on empanadas, convinced the concept of these leaden
slippers was inherently flawed. But Hacienda's panoply
of empanadas (five fillings, from provolone and sausage
to sautéed mushrooms) showed me the light. A sampler
plate rides in on a skiff that looks fashioned from
bark. Each is distinctly toothsome, but the densely
packed spinach and Reggiano outstrips the rest.
If you're
thinking links, the grilled sausage sampler lets you pit
the paprika spice of a Spanish chorizo against the
smokiness of the salchicha or the sweetness of the
national chorizo.
Among the
salads, all sprinkled with spry rock salt, try the grape
tomatoes partnered with cucumbers, leached of their
water for a charismatic crunch.
If your
taste buds lean toward gaucho bravura, try the
pork-blood sausage. So often granular, here the filling
is velvety smooth and chocolaty in its swarthy
sweetness. Playful yellow-green pear tomatoes must have
jumped right off the vine.
Humbly
grilled and oh-so-tender sweetbreads make for a
sweetheart of a starter.
Since the
importation of Argentine meat is currently banned,
Hacienda serves grass-fed, natural, Australian beef in
its stead, along with USDA prime. Both come in a shell
steak or filet mignon cut. You pick the size (from a
"ladies'" 10-ounce lomo to a 16-ounce bife befitting the
beefiest Texan).
The natural
beef may be slightly tougher (you'll be grateful for
that pampas-clearing scythe in your hand), but it pays
back in a flavor so earthy you can smell the warm
breezes quivering through the grass. The American beef
is more tender, to be sure, but despite its sexy
marbling, fades to bland by comparison. Both come with a
tangy chimichurri sauce that, at times, was just a tad
lean.
If you
don't eat red meat, you might feel like a wallflower.
The grilled whole sea bass will change that - especially
if you douse it with chimichurri.
All the
entrees are served solo on gigantic white plates, making
for a dramatic presentation. (Against this stark-white
backdrop, the smoky, charred short rib looks like a
railroad tie.)
Among side
dishes, the papas fritas scented with lemon juice were
more alluring than the garlic fritas. Neither was very
crisp.
Order the
house gnocchi instead, so petite, light and fluffy an
Italian might be thrown. They are smothered in basil and
fresh grape tomatoes bursting out of their thin skins,
as though trampled on a ballroom floor. More rock salt,
por favor.
Chocolate
lovers will find happiness in a dark chocolate flan or a
molten torta de chocolate. More typical are the
alfajores, sugar cookies layered with dulce de leche and
dipped in chocolate, and the much more satisfying
panqueque, a delicate crepe oozing with dulce de leche
and sautéed bananas.
Wash it all
down with some Fernet-Branca, a bark-infused digestif
known for its stomach-settling qualities. Some at our
table thought it tasted like Bactine.
My biggest
complaint about this cozy hacienda is the music, which
ricochets from romantic Cuban guitar to the Red Hot
Chili Peppers to Barry White.
Hacienda de
Argentina celebrates the food and culture of a people
who have music in their blood. I'm not crying for a
guitar-strumming payador - just a soundtrack that
reflects the otherwise pitch-perfect ambience.